Recent blog posts
- The Benefits of Cod Liver Oil on the Skin
- The Benefits of Cod Liver Oil on the Skin
- The Benefits of Cod Liver Oil on the Skin
- Face lift Beverly Hills
- Sunday Updates
- Pard’ners and Best Friends
- Looking for authentic Western Humor and Adventure?
- Horse Crazy Followup & Thank You
- how to cook salmon
- Out at Stan's blog today!
True Grit Remake
I was not a great fan of John Wayne growing up and I still am not. However, everyone is talking about his role and award for the character Rooster Cogburn. The role he played in the movie "In Harm's Way" made me see the kind of actor he truly was. His mannerisms, speach pattern, and human nature were not catagorized so a completely new character emerged and made me sit up and take notice. When he was presented with the Oscar my immediate reaction was he should have gotten it for his role in "In Harm's Way" and not his longtime association with the west and westerns.
When is Hollywood going to get off their duffs and actually write an original screenplay for a good western or any movie for that matter. We are seeing remake after remake these days. This film in no way compares to the original and to say it's one of the top ten of all westerns is totally insane. Let's look at AFI's (American Film Institute) list of top 10 westerns they made just 2 years ago. Not only did John Wayne have 3 films in the top 10, one of his westerns was named the #1 Western of all time.
#1 - The Searchers
#2 - High Noon
#3 - Shane
#4 - Unforgiven
#5 - Red River
#6 - The Wild Bunch
#7 - Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid
#8 - McCabe and Mrs. Miller
#9 - Stagecoach
#10 - Cat Ballou
Look at this list, Duke took #1, #5 and #9. No way can this shotty remake even come close to any of these films. Duke's True Grit not only won an Oscar for Best Actor he also won a Golden Globe for Best Actor. Duke also won the Laurel Aawrd for Best Actor and the film won the Western Heritage Award. Now way can this remake compare.
John Wayne was not only an amazing Actor but an amazing man and humanitarian. Why else would he have been awarded the Congressional Gold Medal and the Presidential Medal of Freedom.
All we heard before this movie was released is how different it was going to be and now that it's been released, that is so far from the truth. Copied scenes, copied lines, no score to speak of and bogus reviews hailing it as the best ever. And since when does a western need computer generated graphics. The only award this new film deserves is the Razzie.
Yes, I'm a John Wayne fan, always have and always will be. I like a good western just as the next guy but this remake is NOT one of them.
John Wayne is "True Grit"
Location
The Searchers was one of John Wayne's best Westerns. John Wayne was good about seeing that his buddies got work in his movies. The crew in 'The Searchers' is a good example. One of my favorite John Wayne movies is not a Western, though. That movie is "The Quiet Man" where he was a retired boxer who moved back to his old family home in Ireland. All his buddies were in that one too. Ward Bond played a priest, Maureen O'Hara was his love interest. One of these days I'll count how many times he made a movie with Maureen O'Hara. Victor McLaughlin played his nemesis who was Maureen O'Hara's brother. They had a wonderful fight scene that probably lasted 15 minutes.
They just don't make movies like that any more.....
Kansas Jack
Location
Opinions belong to the owner, but are shared with all. I saw the new True Grit on Friday Evening and the original on Sat. evening. Both movies were so similar, even down to the dialog, that comparisons can only be made on personal preference. And, can you believe it, my wife's opinions differ from mine!!!
I preferred John Wayne's portrayal of Rooster Cogburn to Jeff Bridges. I preferred Matt Damon's portrayal of LaBoeff to Glen Campbell's. I was neutral on Mattie's portrayal. I preferred Strother Martin's part as the Colonel, but that's probably because I'm a fan of Strother Martin, especially his part in Cool Hand Luke where he says, "What we have here is a failure to communicate." I preferred Robert Duvall as Ned Pepper, even though it was a relatively small part. Again, who can forget Duval in 'Apocalypse Now' where he says, "I love the smell of napalm in the morning."
Overall, I liked both movies, but I think I prefer the original. Maybe it's because Rooster lost his eye at the battle of Lone Jack, 15 miles West of Pittsville, where I live.
Kansas Jack
I havent' seen the movie and it's been a while since I watched the John Wayne version. In the remake isn't the patch on a different eye?
Location
Yes the eye patch is worn on the other eye, annieoakley. It's an excellent film that has received many great reviews. It also has taken the box office lead in money makers during the past two weeks. However, there are some parts that seem wrong in the movie but while most wanted to criticize Jeff Bridges vs John Wayne, the film doesn't do this. It's a story about a young girl and this movie shows this part much better than the original.
Bob Boze Bell, True West Magazine gave it his thumbs up along with film critic Roger Ebert. It you love western movies, it is a must see.
Last year, Jeff Bridges won an Oscar for Crazy Heart. It was not a western movie but it was country. Jeff does his role with superb justice as Roaster Cogburn as does the rest of the casting crew.
Not a western movie, but as country opens this weekend the movie "COUNTRY STRONG" which too is a very good film. I do not believe it will over take True Grit but it's worth watching and has a superb sound track.
http://cowboyandchuckwagoncooking.blogspot.com/2011/01/feel-your-hand-yo...
Roger Edison
Location
I was a big fan of the book and must say I have enjoyed both movie versions. I think Jeff Bridges is more the Rooster Cogburn of the book and certainly Matt Damon was the better Texas Ranger..still, neither quite does justice to the book. John Wayne certainly did a fine job of it in the original movie. I truly liked them both.
Ronni Lea Fox
I love Jeff Bridges, but no amount of imitation of John Wayne can validate this remake. Wayne is the epitome of the Western/tough guy actor- though Robert Mitchem was good, and others of that era as well. They just weren't The Duke. Based on previews ( I won't spend money to see this one- maybe later on television), I vote no way can it measure up.
Location
The best western movie made in years....it is not a movie about John Wayne, it is a movie about a young girl wanting to revenge the killer of her father. John Wayne did a great job in the 1969 movie where he earned his only Oscar. However, this is not a review on his movie. This is one about 2010 and the superb film brought back by directors Joel and Ethan Coen. However due to so much hoopla....about the Duke, one can not review this movie without justifying an unnecessary discussion and comparison.
I don't need to fill you with all the dialog of what the movie is about. What it is not is anything that takes away from the DUKE and in reality, brings much more awareness of John Wayne if anything. In 2010, the Duke has been Googled and Yahooed more than any other year. Additional, while VHS tapes and DVD's have sat unrented collecting dust at Blockbusters, netflixs and others....Out of no where, attention to the 1969 make of True-Grit became the 2010 holiday rental. Those who desire to argue points and have not seen the movie is much like speaking worthless breaths of air to a band of folks that remain blinded because they have made up their mind that nothing is better than John Wayne.
Well, some would argue John Wayne avoided the draft during World War II despite than many war pictures he did or he was a tempered man of three marriages or maybe even racist during a comment made while being interviewed. Although, I personally liked the Duke and he has received two special Presidential Awards. I've read his history, viewed his movies and appreciated what the man appeared to be. The Duke appeared to be the American Cowboy and his movies have been well worth watching. Regardless, I remained unbiased as to how good this 2010 remake movie would be. I needed to see it for myself.
I had planned on seeing it Christmas Day but it was sold out. Not just one show, but the whole entire day. A good friend Vernon Mortersen got to see it early during a sneak preview held in San Diego where Vernon is a producer. He also served in the Navy with naval Special Warfare so I felt he has a grip on not only the movies, but what is real and believable and what is not believable. He told me it was great but rather than speak much about Bridges, told me to check out Berry Pepper. Thumbs up from
Vernon.
The Holiday schedule had myself busy unable to see it until New Years day. However, by then, Bob Boze Bell gave his review. Bob owns True West Publishing and narrates with the ENCORE Western Movie Cable channel. He quoted "Last night the entire family, six of us, went to see the new "True Grit" and all agreed it is a winner. Tonight, Kathy and I watched the original and it's amazing, both stand tall, with slight differences and advantages." I even had to read Roger Ebert's review who also gave it thumbs up and believes maybe it's time to do the remake of the Broadway Hit Musical "Oklahoma."
However, this is the Grit of True Grit. I saw it. I liked it. I liked it better than the first. I was highly impressed with the screenwriters selection of dialogs and expressions that fit the movie. I can dig fault in any movie and found two parts I thought could have been different, but if one read the book, you would appreciate a director who does justice by not changing things from the book as perhaps director Henry Hathaway did in the first movie making the picture more about Rooster Cogburn rather than
Mattie Ross, the educated sharp tongue 14 year old girl from Arkansas.
Don't be surprise when this movie goes up for at least 5 academy awards. The acting is superb. The wardrobe is impeccable to the era portrayed and the folklore and action all so realistic that it is a believable tale. Although, I believe 2010 has a hand full of great movies. It would be unlikely to receive the top award for best picture though if Bridges won best actor in this movie, it would make Oscar History as I do not know of another which has won this award and then do it again. Each character plays their role as directed by the Coen brothers and they each did a superb job.
This morning over coffee, Jennifer Schmidt shared some of her thoughts as we disused the highlights. She too loves the Duke though desired and longed for another good western. As we talked about actors that might have been able to play this part, actors like Robert Duval who played the lead in Lonesome Dove couldn't because he played bad guy Ned Pepper in the original. Clint Eastwood would have had his flare but would be difficult to see him playing anything but his own roles. One name we both agreed upon was maybe Billy Bob Thornton who is also from Arkansas and has a very unique way of being any role his portrays. However, the role was given to Jeff Bridges.
Bridges who perhaps is best known for his roles in Starman, Iron man or Tron but wait a minute, didn't Jeff just win an academy award? Yes he did in the 2009 movie "Crazy Heart" Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role. Oh and the movie was a modern western about a broke down country singer on a come back.....and oddly, watching True Grit for its second time, and ICON fades and another begins. Bridges has had some other roles in westerns too. One along side Clint Eastwood in the 1974 "Thunderbolt and Lightfoot." Later the not so proclaim western "Rancho Delux" stealing cattle which was basically the story of two dumb idiots. Then there was "Texasville" which is the story about west Texas booming oil towns and more money than good ole white trash America knows what to do with it. The book was better but Bridges can act and does better than good in True Grit. That's great acting.
As Jennifer continued comments, we both agreed about Josh Brolin playing the role of Tom Chaney seemed weak. However, perhaps because Chaney is the hired hand who killed his employer in the mannerism of showing Chaney as weak and perhaps not intended to make out as heroic. She too, gave her thumbs up and we both agreed that the directors could had portrayed this man tougher or perhaps fearing. Maybe it was to not take away from Barry Pepper playing the role of gang leader Ned Pepper which Robert Duval played in the first make.
I found two scenes I personally wished where different. One is the scene of the medicine like man wearing the bear suit. It's a cool idea but seems to miss something until later making the audience laugh. The other is towards the end as one rides off on a horse doubled and passes an available horse. No Cowboy would leave a horse that he could switch out with but this is Hollywood. Plus what man would ever stab a horses thing to make it continue running.....unless you really wanted to shake up an audience in a manner and believe this would make a horse desiring to quit continue. It must have worked because when it occurs, you hear moans coming from those peering into the screen as they push back or flinch in the seats.
Money Talks: On Christmas day, the money makers at the box office openers was "Little Fockers" and "Tron the Legacy." True Grit trailed miles behind. Completing this first week, True Grit edges the Little Fockers and surpasses Tron by miles. I do not believe this is the best movie of 2010. However, it is the best Western this year and it is a must see picture. Anything to believe different because John Wayne once played the role of Rooster Cogburn would be doltish. I will state it should be one of the best five movies this year did see as we enter into 2011.
What matter most about seeing this movie was my company at the movies. I took my son and he not only loved the movie. He enjoyed the company of his Dad. He never ICON John Wayne and doesn't know him like I did growing up. He merely is the same age of the young Mattie Ross and said this was the best western movie he had every seen next to Dancing with Wolves....that tells me, it's a hit to the young and the old. FOUR STARS
Well, Jeff Bridges played the role in a different spin. I like both ways this movie was portrayed but this remark is in my opinion, better.
The cinematography was beyond excellence. The language real
Roger Edison
Poll
- Login or register to post comments
- 716 reads
- Older polls





Recent comments
2 hours 50 min ago
2 hours 59 min ago
14 hours 5 min ago
22 hours 15 min ago
22 hours 27 min ago
22 hours 31 min ago
1 day 3 hours ago
1 day 6 hours ago
1 day 6 hours ago
1 day 13 hours ago